12 Best Cottage Cheeses You Will Love

Cottage Cheese

Cottage cheese has made a firm stance among cheese lovers all over the world. Not only is it incredibly tasty by itself, but it’s also extremely versatile and can be used in many different forms and various meals. All those positive aspects make cottage cheese a go-to dairy option for many people, and therefore, such a product deserves an article that will talk everything about it. Other cheeses can wait a bit!

We stumbled across one issue. And it’s that the market is flooded with high-quality cottage cheese. So, how to pick the best one? In this article, we’ll give our recommendations on some of the best cottage cheese options out there and hopefully, after reading this, you’ll pick the one that works best for your taste buds. 

We’ll also cover some essential recipes and how to use this incredible product into your advantage so that your meals become top-notch. Keep in mind that the order of products on the list is entirely random and therefore, we can’t pinpoint which one is the best out there. You’ll need to pick that yourself. 

So, without further ado let’s hop into the world of cottage cheese.

Mountain House Cottage Cheese

First, on the list, we have one product from a well-established creator – Mountain House. It’s creamy and low on fat which equals a perfect match. Not only does it go well with milk, but you can just pour a bit of water, and you’ll have a fantastic side dish. 

Since Mountain House is a big name, you’ll usually be able to find their cottage cheese in the nearest supermarket – meaning it’s the first pick if you want something safe and you don’t want to experiment a lot. But, despite that, this cheese is far from mediocre. It tastes great, and most people swear by it. Try it with some macaroni, and you’ll love it! 

Good Culture Classic Cottage Cheese

Good Culture is another brand that offers tasty cottage cheese. It’s low on fat – only 2% which makes it great if you want a healthy meal but also if you don’t wish to get cheese with a stronger taste. Besides, it’s great to mix with other ingredients. You can put some garlic in it, salt, pepper, you name it. It kind of has a neutral taste which is excellent since you can play around with it. 

It also comes in a sweet minimalistic package which you won’t stop looking at for days since it’s made very stylish. But if you decide to open in, you’ll discover a neat all-round cottage cheese.

Amish Greek

Oh, Greek cuisine. If you’re a fan of it, you’ll adore this creamy cottage cheese. Apart from having ancient gods in the past, you can pretty much say that Greeks are gods of cuisine as well. They have so many exciting products which found their place in kitchens all around the world.

Amish Greek cottage cheese is one of them. It’s great cheese that isn’t much salty meaning it could be served multiple times throughout the day. Breakfast, lunch or dinner, you name it. If you add some olives and vine to it, you’ll surely feel like a mighty Greek god. 

Breakstones Small Curd Cottage Cheese

If you’re looking for a dairy product that has low calories and fat, look no more. Breakstone’s cottage cheese is probably the healthiest one on the market since it’s so low on the fat you could probably call it fat-free. If you want to stay fit but don’t want to stop eating your favourite cheese, this cottage cheese will be the perfect option for you.

It comes in various sizes, but most of them are very portable, meaning you could take them with you and include it into your daily diet. It’s also great if you just want to make your meal healthier overall. We all know how much dairy products can contribute to increased cholesterol and so on, but if you pick this cheese, you might not need to think about that at all.

Pirate’s Booty White Cheddar

Cheddar? What’s cheddar doing on this list. We know – it might look questionable, but white cheddar is here for a reason. Why? Because Pirate’s Booty White Cheddar is ultimately a variation of cottage cheese. Puffed with corn and rice, it’s an excellent snack for the whole family. It doesn’t have any artificial colours, and it’s gluten-free and low on fat. If you add to that the fact that it’s incredibly easy to make, you can see why it’s a great option to have if you want a quick snack with your friends or family.

Oh, and it has a cool name. Pirate Booty. 

Nancy’s Cottage Cheese

And yet another great cheese that is low on fat. It offers everything already mentioned above: great taste with low fat that’s also gluten-free. If you want to keep a healthy diet but still want to eat dairy products, Nancy’s cottage cheese is a way to go. It’s not better from the competition, but it’s not a whole lot worse—just a regular safe pick when it comes to cottage cheese.

Organic Valley Cottage Cheese

We all know how organic foods are becoming more and more recognizable among people all over the world. Not only that they are incredibly healthy and tasty, but by using them, you kind of save our nature, and that’s great. 

Organic Valley cottage cheese is great because it’s natural (obviously), but apart from that, it tastes like a regular non-organic cheese! Which is fantastic since most organic products have a different taste to them. It’s also low on fat and comes in a 16oz container which is pretty convenient to use as you can store it in the fridge and use it whenever you want to. 

Another benefit of this cheese is that it’s made from the milk of the cows that live on small family farms so you really get a feel that you’re eating something special and sort of hand made. It’s just great.

Lactaid 1% Low Fat Cottage Cheese

The only lactose-free cheese on this list. It’s so well made that you won’t even notice it doesn’t have lactose in it. It’s effortless to digest and tasty at the same time, so you don’t lose much if you pick this over others on the list. The fact that they added the lactase-enzyme into the cheese itself and made it lactate-free deserves all the praise it can get, but the fact that the taste remained spectacular as with other cheeses is out of this world. 

And to blast your mind, even more, the cheese has a whopping 12 grams of protein in every pot which will help you get through your day with ease. 

Daisy 4% Cottage Cheese

Having a bit more fat than their competition, Daisy cottage cheese is super creamy and incredibly tasty. This product is all-natural with no added extra ingredients to make it more creamy (which other manufactures do a lot). 

Mixed in lasagne or macaroni, it will make an unforgettable meal which you will keep going back to every once in a while. 

Horizon Organic Cottage Cheese

Many people say that this is the best organic cottage cheese out there. And they aren’t wrong. Made from natural ingredients, the guys from Horizon have created a natural, tasty, creamy and rich with vitamins cottage cheese which is a full pack that everyone needs. 

It’s great for people who want to stay healthy but also for those who like the taste of creamy cheese that’s rich in flavour. Add the fact that it has 15% DV of calcium/serving, and you can easily see why this cheese is a pick for most of the organic cheese lovers out there. 

Knudsen Cottage Cheese

One more excellent all-round cottage cheese presented on this list. Rich in flavour, with low fat, Knudsen cottage cheese is great if you don’t want to experiment a lot with your pick and should be considered for almost everyone. It’s faulty cheap, and since it’s neutral, it goes well with most ingredients you mix it up.

Hood Low Fat Cottage Cheese

Last but not least, the Hood offers great cottage cheese for a reasonable price. Similar to others on this list, it’s a great all-rounder cheese that has a low-fat margin. So, if you’re looking for something quite easy to mix with and you want to keep your weight under control, Hood low fat cottage cheese is a way to go. 


There you have it—a long list of some of the best cottage cheeses out there. Now, bear in mind that the order of the products on the list doesn’t mean anything. Every single one of them is great in their way and if you want to be sure which one works for you – there’s no way around it. You’ll need to try them all.

If you happen to be on a keto diet we got another article that might be interesting for you. We talked about keto diet and cheese and made a little handy guide for all you cheese lovers on a keto diet.

Cheesy Guru

Cheesy guru bringing you hot topics from the cheese world. Stay up to date with the latest trends from the industry or learn about cheeses you never knew about. All this in one place, your go-to website when it comes to cheese - Cheese Buzz!

Recent Content